Steel coils travel in both worlds. Narrow slit coils under 15 tonnes ride in containers with coil cradles; wide heavy-gauge coils go breakbulk, plain and simple. Between those poles sit shipments where the economics genuinely compete — and the comparison is closer than most shippers expect.
The container case
A 20-foot container takes roughly 24 to 26 tonnes of steel, and coils secured in cradles discharge cleanly with a reach stacker. Container freight avoids lashing surveys entirely, the cargo never touches a quay until discharge, and transit is faster on scheduled services. For coils under about 12 tonnes and above roughly four loads, the per-tonne freight often comes within 10 percent of breakbulk.
The breakbulk case
Coils above 15 tonnes, coils needing through-shipment to a non-container berth, and mixed shipments where coils travel with structural steel all push toward breakbulk. Multipurpose vessels discharge by vessel crane at any quay, so the destination can be a project site jetty rather than a container terminal. The trade-off is lashing: coils need strapping, wedges and turnbuckles, and the lashing plan is inspected before sailing.
The hidden third variable: handling at destination
Container discharge puts a reach stacker in charge; breakbulk discharge puts the vessel crane and a coil ram in charge. If the inland leg cannot lift 15-tonne units, a breakbulk price that looks per-tonne cheaper becomes expensive on the last 40 kilometres. Quote the whole chain or the comparison is fiction.
Insurance and claim behaviour
Containerised coils claim less often — no double handling — but claims when they occur involve the cradle, which not all policies price kindly. Breakbulk claims concentrate on edge damage from neighbouring cargo. Share your insurance terms before the mode decision; the premium difference can swing the comparison more than the freight difference.
The decision sequence
Check unit weight against container limits, then handling at destination, then sailing frequency against your delivery window. We price both modes when the answer is borderline — the spread on the China–Middle East trade is usually under 8 percent, and the handling reality decides it.
Send the dimensions and the lane. A planner will come back with options.