Small exporters default to LCL because the invoice is smaller. Per cubic metre it is almost always more expensive — you are paying for shared handling. The honest comparison is per shipment at your actual volume, including the costs LCL quietly adds.
The crossover math
LCL is priced per cubic metre or tonne with minimums; FCL is priced per box. On the China–Middle East trade, LCL rates run 45 to 70 dollars per cubic metre against a 20-foot FCL in the 1,200 to 1,800 range. Around 15 to 18 cubic metres of usable, stackable cargo, FCL wins on freight. Below 10, LCL usually does.
What LCL adds beyond the rate
Consolidation and deconsolidation fees at both warehouses, longer transit (the box waits for fullness), double handling that produces the classic LCL damage profile, and destination charges that shock shippers who quoted origin-only. Destination LCL handling at congested ports can exceed the origin freight on small lots — always quote destination charges into the comparison.
The breakage variable
LCL cargo shares its box with strangers’ cargo. Compression damage on unstackable cartons is the most common LCL claim, and packing that survives FCL often fails LCL. Palletise, strap and label for a box you do not control. The pallets cost less than the claims.
Where breakbulk fits between them
Machinery too heavy or too large for a container but too small to justify a charter travels as breakbulk on multipurpose vessels — priced per revenue tonne with a share of the lashing. For pieces above container limits, it is not a comparison; it is the only option. For pieces under the limits but over two tonnes, price both: multipurpose rates can surprise container rates on the dense trades.
Practical advice
Price your next shipment both ways with destination charges included. If the numbers are close, take FCL for the control and the speed; if they are far apart, take LCL and pack for the box you are actually getting.
Send the dimensions and the lane. A planner will come back with options.